Mary and I have been watching this years season of American Idol. I don't like was American Idol represents but I am drawn to the show. I have never voted; not that I'm against voting, but I like keeping my 95 cents. Last week we watched the American Idol: Idol Gives back show. It was hosted by
Ellen DeGeneres and Ryan Seacrest. The show featured a mysterious and amazing performance by Celine Dion and Elvis Presley doing a duet of "If I Can Dream," Josh Groban, who was backed by the African Children's Choir on "You
Raise Me Up"; Kelly Clarkson, who sang Patty Griffin's "Up to the
Mountain" with riffs from Beck; and Carrie Underwood,
who filmed her performance of the Pretenders' "I'll Stand by You"
during her trip to an orphanage in Africa, Rascal Flatts' "My Wish"
The performances were couched in between filmed segments of the impoverished, the needy and the ill. The producers of the show superbly paced and alternated between information and entertainment, allowing the message to stand out from the music. I sat patiently, as I expect Paula Abdul's bust-enhancing top to experience a wardrobe malfunction at the hands of Ryan Seacrest, but it never happened.
The show raise somewhere around $30 million dollars for their charities, which is just mind blowing for a one night show. Yet, I could not help but wonder, will money really solve problems? Can we throw money at Africa and expect that things will be changed? As a Christian, I believe that Christ in people bring change, not money. I don't want to say that American Idol should not have raised money because some unbelievable good can be done with that kind of money, but I have the nagging, piercing feeling that just tossing money at a problem won't make the systemic changes that need to be made. Anyone got thoughts?